Lost Report 13—The Finale May 30, 2008
And now we know. This fulfilling, sometimes heart-wrenching episode allowed us to say goodbye for another eight months, wrapping up some stories and starting others, and most importantly, offering an answer to a season-long question. Who’s in the coffin?
1. I’ll start with the obvious—John Locke is the man in the coffin. (Kudos to all who theorized as much!) We saw Jack come to the unofficial “funeral” for the unidentified individual back at the season’s beginning. Now we know. Somehow, the man whom Ben left in charge of the group of Others is dead and off the island some four years later. This is after he initiated contact with at least some of the Oceanic 6 under the alias “Jeremy Bentham,” presumably to protect his identity. Of course we all want to know what happened. We’ll just have to wait. I, however, believe that Ben has everything fully under control to design the outcome he desires.
2. On Doc Jensen’s teaser, I read this quote from executive producer Carlton Cuse: “Our characters’ fates and our story for the season all come down to this: Who’s right about the island? Jack the empiricist or Locke the man of faith?” Did anyone think that question was answered in the finale? On first thought, I’d say Locke, the man of faith, was right. Jack is desolate in his life off the island, separated from Kate, addicted to painkillers and booze, and relentlessly attempting to get back. But then, we were shown Locke’s body in the coffin. Why did this man, who truly loved the island, apparently leave it? Or did he? Did he acquire the ability to time travel? Is he really dead? Time will tell.
3. Once again, Michael Emerson’s acting completely convinced me that Benjamin Linus is in total control of what is happening on this show. He has been surprised a few times—one, when his daughter was killed, and two, when he learned that Keamy’s arm could signal a bomb aboard the freighter. Even when surprised, though, he quickly regains the upper hand. He is a master at appearing innocent at one moment and showing icy madness the next. I’m not certain exactly what motivates him. He doesn’t seem to love anyone. Even with Alex, their relationship seemed to be possessor and possessed. Ben pined for Juliet, but he completely creeped her out by killing her beloved, Goodman. What is behind his actions? It can’t be money. He’s obviously got access to plenty of that. When we look back at his childhood—basically killing his mother through his own birth, then being hated and constantly berated by his father—we can see the beginnings of a man who wants no one to manipulate him. Instead, he wants to be the manipulator. And boy is he good at it. Before he even went down below, why did Ben say to John, “We’re going somewhere cold”? He didn’t allow John to go, so who’s “we”? There was one moment in this episode when Ben was alone. He had climbed down into the icy chamber below the Orchid and was about to turn the huge wheel, when he looked up and said, “I hope you’re happy, Jacob.” Almost as if he were talking to God. Someone please tell me what this means. When Ben turned the wheel, the island moved. It was quite a sight for those on the out-of-fuel chopper…and for me…when the island was swallowed by the sea. Where did it go? (As for the island disappearing, I can’t believe the poor survivors had to endure another crash when the chopper fell into the sea.)
4. Poor Daniel Faraday. His would-be girlfriend Charlotte chose to stay on the island. What a mystery. Miles saw within her that she has been on the island before. As they said goodbye, Charlotte reminded Daniel that she has been “looking for where I was born.” Hmmm. Miles is staying put, too, so hopefully we’ll get some good information on these two next season.
5. What is going on with Sun in the off-island future? She has become a powerful, wealthy, controlling woman. What is her motivation for working with Charles Widmore? Indirectly, he was responsible for her husband’s death. Which brings me to dear Jin. It appears that he died when the freighter blew up. What a heart-wrenching scene to watch her screaming for him! What an unreadable look she threw at Jack when he told her “he’s gone.” Later, we learn that she blames Jack for what happened to Jin. Does Sun think Jin might still be living? Is she hoping to do some time travel to reverse the events? Is that even possible? Does she simply want to find his body?
6. The ageless Other Richard Alpert and his crew ended up helping the Oceanic 6 get off the island—for the hefty price of rescuing Ben from Keamy and his baddies. Why doesn’t Richard appear to age? Why didn’t John Locke appear to recognize Richard back when he first went to the Other camp (when they had his kidney-stealing father)? Surely you can’t forget a face like that, even if you meet him when you’re a child. What are the Others doing? Where are they living? What do they plan to do with Locke as their leader? What do they do, exactly?
7. Mr. Indestructible Keamy did eventually die, resulting in a blown-up freighter and, supposedly, a dead Michael (given passage into the afterlife by Christian Shephard, nonetheless!) and Jin. Keamy died because Ben had a Psycho moment of revenge for Alex’s death, even though he knew killing Keamy would kill possibly dozens of others.
8. We got to see teenaged Walt when he visited Hurley at the mental institution. I hope the passage of time will explain how old he looked. I’m not sure when that scene was supposed to have taken place. Kate told bearded Jack at one point that it had been three years since he’d left her and Aaron, so by the time Jack goes wack, they’ve been off the island for some four years, perhaps. Was this when Walt came to visit? And when was Sayid’s late-night visit to Hurley, interrupting his chess game with an invisible Mr. Eko to urge him to come along to a place where they’ll be safe? “We’re being watched,” Sayid insisted. Why are they all in such danger?
9. Kate’s dream was downright terrifying—a supposed intruder, only to become Claire, who warned Kate not to bring Aaron back to the island. Later, when Ben startled Jack at the funeral parlor, and just before we saw Locke in the coffin, Ben said he had some ideas about how to get them all back on the island. Then he added, “I said all of you. We’re gonna have to bring him too,” and nodded at Locke. Does “all” mean the six, plus Locke, and possibly plus others? Don’t I remember someone saying there were others who left the island? Or did that mean Locke, aside from the six?
10. Can I just say I’m glad I get to enjoy Sawyer for a few more episodes, at least? After his plummet into the sea, I wasn’t so sure, but his bare-chested return to the beach, after swimming what could have been a mile or two, made me feel better. (: How could we do without that Southern drawl and the plethora of hilarious nicknames? (Lapidus=”Kenny Rogers”!)
Okay, my husband just sighed and went up to bed. Clearly he thinks this “report” is running too long. I took about a page of notes while I watched. It has been so much to process. And still, still, still I have more questions than answers. I suppose that is the genius—and the frustration—of the show. Until next year…























